Democracy on the Brink: Historians Saw This Coming
How Years of Warnings About Trump and Authoritarianism Went Unheeded
The storm clouds of democratic erosion didn’t appear overnight. For years, leading historians and scholars have issued grave warnings about the fragility of democracy in America and the world.
Christopher R. Browning, Timothy Snyder, Anne Applebaum, and others sounded alarms, drawing parallels to the dark periods of history when authoritarianism took hold.
Today, those warnings feel chillingly prophetic. From the erosion of democratic norms to the rise of leaders who thrive on division, many of the same patterns that destabilized democracies in the past are playing out again.
This article examines what these experts warned, how their predictions came to pass, and what we must do now to safeguard our future.
The Fragility of Democracy
Democracies don’t fall in a single catastrophic event. They unravel gradually, often with the complicity or complacency of those who should defend them.
What History Teaches Us
Christopher R. Browning warned about this in his essay The Suffocation of Democracy, comparing modern America to the interwar period when political polarization, economic disparity, and isolationism gave rise to authoritarian regimes.
Authoritarianism thrives on fear and division. Historical parallels abound, from leaders scapegoating minorities to sowing distrust in institutions.
These tactics weaken democratic systems, making them vulnerable to leaders who promise order but deliver oppression.
The Warning Signs
Browning identified early indicators of democratic suffocation: the erosion of checks and balances, populist rhetoric that undermines institutions, and growing inequality.
His work serves as a roadmap for recognizing these dangers before it’s too late.
Warnings from the Experts
Historians and political scientists have been vocal about their concerns, issuing clear warnings that align eerily with today’s challenges.
What Scholars Told Us
Timothy Snyder’s On Tyranny offers 20 lessons from the 20th century, each a guide to resisting authoritarianism. Snyder urged vigilance against small erosions of freedoms, noting that the collapse of democracy often begins with minor, unnoticed steps.
Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt, in How Democracies Die, highlighted how norms, not just laws, are crucial for democratic survival.
Their research emphasized the role of political elites in protecting or undermining democracy. The alignment of these elites with authoritarian tendencies accelerates democratic decline.
Anne Applebaum and the Allure of Authoritarianism
In Twilight of Democracy, Anne Applebaum examined why authoritarianism appeals to segments of society. She pointed to political polarization, disinformation, and the human tendency to seek simple solutions in chaotic times.
Applebaum’s work underscores the social and psychological forces that enable democratic backsliding.
Ignored Warnings, Predictable Outcomes
Despite the clarity and urgency of these warnings, the public and political establishment often failed to take them seriously.
Why Warnings Fell on Deaf Ears
Much of the public and political establishment dismissed the concerns of historians and scholars. Partisan media outlets fueled misinformation, trivializing the threats and amplifying the voices of those undermining democratic norms.
Complacency also played a role. Many believed that America’s institutions were too strong to fail or that authoritarianism could never take root here. That confidence proved misplaced as systemic vulnerabilities were exploited.
The Cost of Inaction
The results are visible today: weakened institutions, eroded public trust, and a political landscape marked by division and hostility. These outcomes were not inevitable but were the predictable result of ignoring history’s lessons.
Lessons for the Present and Future
History isn’t just a story of the past—it’s a guide to navigating the present and future challenges.
Steps to Safeguard Democracy
Action is required at every level of society to protect democracy. Scholars like Snyder and Applebaum emphasize the importance of informed civic engagement, supporting independent journalism, and defending institutions.
Citizens must remain vigilant, resist apathy, and hold leaders accountable. This means voting, participating in activism, and combating disinformation wherever it spreads.
Learning from the Past
Recognizing the parallels between past and present isn’t enough; we must act on that knowledge. The responsibility to safeguard democracy doesn’t lie solely with politicians or activists—it’s a collective effort.
A Moment for Action
The fight for democracy isn’t over. Each of us has a role to play in pushing back against authoritarianism and protecting democratic values.
Stay informed and inspired—join my Substack community today!
Paid subscribers receive weekly eBooks that dive deeper into select topics.