He's Scary Now, But Wait 'Til You See His Wikipedia Entry in 2050
Trump: Today's Nightmare, Tomorrow's Historic Footnote
Let’s be real: things feel grim. Trump’s back. The government is being “streamlined” by DOGE.
The news is a steady drip of dread. Mass deportations to El Salvador. Rumors of sending people to Libya. Plans to reopen Alcatraz. ICE raids. Reporters, lawyers, and judges are all in the crosshairs.
It’s exhausting. Even the calmest history buff might reach for the smelling salts.
It’s scary—no doubt about it.
But before you start building a bunker or learning to live off the grid, take a breath. Yes, this is scary stuff. But it's not the apocalypse in the larger sweep of American history. In fact, it’s not even original.
In the grand, sprawling epic of time, even the most bombastic figures can end up as little more than a curious footnote.
The "Imperial Presidency"- Not Exactly a Trump Original
The truth is, the "imperial presidency," as scholars like UC Berkeley’s Daniel Farber call it, isn't a brand-new Trump™ invention. It's a fascinating wrinkle of American history that this expansion of executive power isn't a partisan creation.
In fact, some of our most revered presidents, often celebrated for their transformative leadership, also significantly expanded executive authority, particularly in times of crisis.
Franklin D. Roosevelt, architect of the New Deal and leader through World War II, did so extensively, creating vast new federal agencies.
Abraham Lincoln, saviour of the Union, took actions like suspending habeas corpus without prior congressional approval.
Even more recent Democratic presidents, like Barack Obama, utilized executive orders to navigate congressional gridlock and advance their agendas.
America has survived big power grabs before, often from presidents we now see in a positive light. Today, their legacies are about much more than just their use of power.
This shows something important: even bold presidential overreach doesn’t define the country forever.
No single president’s actions, including Trump’s, are likely to be the final word. Attempts to grab more power usually turn out to be short chapters in a bigger story.
In the long run, these moments fade. They become minor parts of history, not the main event.
Political Theater vs. The Unshakeable Bureaucracy
It’s also crucial to understand what’s genuinely a systemic threat versus what might be, for lack of a better term, political showmanship.
Many executive orders, for instance, are more like loud public memos than unshakeable laws.
As some policy experts have noted, sometimes these orders are more about "checking the box" for campaign promises without having a massive immediate impact.
This isn't to downplay the real harm and fear caused by current policies; the canceled research grants, the redirected civil rights enforcement, and the terror in immigrant communities are painfully real.
Yet, the most sweeping changes often collide with the stubborn realities of law, the inertia of bureaucracy, and the eventual pushback from the judiciary.
The courts, bless their robed hearts, still function as a powerful check, and Congress, despite appearances, still holds the power of the purse.
Been There, Survived That: America's Past Brushes with Tyranny
This brings us to the comforting, if sometimes sobering, perspective of history. America has faced down its own versions of tyranny before.
Remember the McCarthy era? In the 1950s, Senator Joseph McCarthy terrorized the nation with baseless accusations, blacklists, and a climate of fear.
Careers were destroyed, lives upended, and the very fabric of American democracy seemed to be unraveling. His tactics – fear, intimidation, relentless attacks – sound eerily familiar, don't they?
Or consider the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II, a decision now universally condemned, where over 100,000 Americans were imprisoned based on their ancestry.
Nixon’s Watergate scandal dragged the nation to the brink of a constitutional crisis with its abuse of power.
Each of these moments felt, to those living through them, like the potential end of American democracy.
And yet, in each instance, the system, often creaking and groaning, eventually righted itself, not by magic, but through the determined actions of individuals and institutions.
The Footnote Fate: How History Remembers Overreach
And how are those figures remembered now? This is where the "footnote" theory really comes into its own.
Think about Benedict Arnold. What’s the one thing everyone knows? He was a traitor. The nuances of his earlier heroism? Mostly lost to the mists of time.
Richard Nixon? For most, his legacy is indelibly linked to Watergate, the Vietnam War, and being the only president to resign.
Indeed, history has a clear pattern: it often remembers figures like McCarthy for disgrace.
However, their grand plans and daily outrages fade, and what remains is the stark summary of their overreach and eventual fall.
It’s a pattern.
History has a habit of condensing the legacies of those who abuse power into cautionary tales, brief mentions of what not to do.
The Enduring Power of "We the People" (And Our Institutions)
This isn't to say we should be complacent. The resilience of American democracy isn't a passive phenomenon. It’s forged in resistance.
During the McCarthy era, it wasn't one hero but a chorus of courageous voices.
There were journalists like Edward R. Murrow exposing lies, lawyers like Joseph Welch demanding decency in the Army-McCarthy hearings, and politicians like Margaret Chase Smith making a "Declaration of Conscience."
There were also countless ordinary citizens who simply refused to be intimidated.
Today, we have even more tools at our disposal. Every smartphone can document, every social media account can amplify.
Coalitions can form, institutions like courts and local governments can be platforms for pushback, and the power of the vote remains paramount.
Scholarly work, such as that of Professor Farber, emphasizes that constitutional law isn't just made in courts; it's made by civil servants who refuse illegal orders, journalists who expose abuses, and citizens who insist on their rights.
Congress’s power of the purse, Senate confirmations, the actions of states, and the independent judiciary all serve as vital checks on executive power, as do grassroots resistance movements.
So, About That Apocalypse...
Yes, the current political theatre, with its plans for a revamped Alcatraz and government "efficiency" departments that sound like they were named by a Bond villain’s less imaginative cousin, is alarming.
The dismantling of federal institutions, the ICE raids, and the targeting of the press and courts are serious and demand unwavering opposition.
But if history is any guide, and it usually is, this too shall pass.
The American system, with its checks and balances, its often-underestimated bureaucratic resilience, and the enduring spirit of its people, has a knack for weathering storms.
When future generations study this period, it's highly probable that Donald Trump, despite the current sound and fury, will be relegated to a few paragraphs in their history texts – a notorious, but ultimately contained figure.
They’ll likely spend more time learning about how democracy bent but didn’t break.
The real headline that will endure won't be about the temporary triumphs of an autocratic agenda, but about the enduring resilience of a democratic republic and the people who fought to keep it.
The arc of American history is indeed long, and it consistently, if sometimes arduously, bends towards that resilience, reform, and ultimately, hope.
Join our fearless community and subscribe now to support uncompromising journalism.
Thank you for supporting unapologetic reporting. Together, we’re keeping the American Dream alive by unleashing the truth!