Your Cheat Sheet for MAGA Myth-Busting This Holiday Season
Debunking the Top 3 MAGA Myths Over the Holidays
The holidays bring joy, family gatherings, and, for many, political debates that can leave you feeling more frazzled than festive.
With Trump returning to the presidency, some of your MAGA relatives might arrive armed with bold claims and questionable “facts.”
This guide equips you with the knowledge to debunk common myths, keeping the peace while staying rooted in truth.
Myth #1: "Trump Won a Decisive Mandate from the American People"
The Claim: Trump declared an “unprecedented and powerful mandate” after the 2024 election.
The Reality: The data paints a different picture. Trump won just under 50% of the popular vote, with a 1.6% margin over Kamala Harris. This is smaller than Hillary Clinton’s popular vote margin in 2016 and far less than the decisive victories of Barack Obama in 2008 and 2012.
Trump’s margin also ranks as the fifth smallest in modern presidential history. While his Electoral College victory was legitimate, it was far from historic.
Rebuttal Strategy: Use historical comparisons to show that mandates require overwhelming support from the electorate. Point out that Trump’s claim is exaggerated and does not reflect the narrow reality of his win.
Myth #2: "Trump Will Use Tariff Money to Eliminate Federal Income Taxes"
The Claim: Trump promises to use tariff revenue to fund the elimination of federal income taxes.
The Reality: Tariffs are taxes on imports paid by businesses importing goods. These costs are passed on to consumers in the form of higher prices. Economists widely agree that tariffs hurt American families and businesses, not foreign governments.
Since the reimplementation of tariffs, companies have reported scaling back year-end bonuses, laying off workers, and planning price hikes.
These outcomes contradict Trump’s claims of economic relief for everyday Americans. Instead of solving economic challenges, tariffs often worsen them.
Rebuttal Strategy: Use real-world examples to show the economic harm tariffs cause. Emphasize that tariffs are not a sustainable source of revenue and highlight the consensus among economists debunking Trump’s promises.
Myth #3: "Trump Won’t Deport Me or My Family"
The Claim: Trump’s immigration policies only target undocumented immigrants.
The Reality: Trump’s first term, under the guidance of Stephen Miller, was marked by policies where “the pain is the point,” such as family separations at the border.
For his second term, Trump has doubled down on these strategies, appointing hardliners like Miller and Thomas Homan to oversee immigration.
His administration has announced plans for mass deportations, a move that could impact not only undocumented immigrants but also lawful residents and even U.S. citizens through errors in enforcement.
Past enforcement efforts have shown the potential for wrongful detentions. Trump’s plans are likely to create widespread fear and chaos, making no one truly safe from scrutiny.
Rebuttal Strategy: Acknowledge the need for border security but stress the importance of humane enforcement. Highlight the risks of aggressive policies leading to overreach and harm to innocent people.
Bonus Section: Surviving Holiday Political Debates
Political discussions over the holidays don’t have to end in conflict. Here are some tips to navigate tense conversations:
Stick to the facts: Avoid personal attacks or emotional reactions.
Know when to disengage: A simple “Let’s agree to disagree” can save the day.
Use humor: A lighthearted comment can defuse tension and shift the mood.
Change the topic: Steer the conversation toward family traditions or shared memories when things get heated.
Sometimes, the best response is to prioritize peace over winning the argument.
Stay informed and inspired—join my Substack community today!
Paid subscribers receive weekly eBooks that dive deeper into select topics.